View Full Version: Board Reviews & Critique

RPG-Directory > Q&A Center > Board Reviews & Critique



Title: Board Reviews & Critique


Jalynn - June 11, 2008 12:29 PM (GMT)
So I noticed we have Plot showcase, writers showcase, character showcase, Play-by help, show off your graphics and what not. But I was wondering if there is a section for Honest open Board reviews. For those who want honest opinions about their boards on what looks good, what does not and such fourth. What they as a Possible member would or wouldn't like about it.

I have searched RPG-D for a while now and haven't found anything like it or asked, grant you it is only 8:30 for me and I might have missed it. So if that is the case, you can Push me off in the right direction or whatnot.

Thank you in advance =)

Mousie - June 11, 2008 02:19 PM (GMT)
There isn't one as yet, unfortunately.

The topic has come up a number of times, and it's something that a lot of people want. However, to staff it and make sure it runs smoothly (people and criticism... always handy to have many mods on board to stop flame wars) it's not something that is quite possible this very instant (at least, that was the previous answer -- staff feel free to correct me here).

But mainly, there is need of working out a system that will ensure boards all get looked at in a fair manner, and that no one gets out of line. As you can imagine - this is a task that requires great thought on the staff behalf, and a workable solution is yet to be found.

So in short -- no there isn't one, and there probably won't be for a while yet.

Jalynn - June 11, 2008 03:01 PM (GMT)
Thanks Mousie for taking the time to Answer this. I can see where there would be an issue with the Flaming and other complaints and the many Mods needed to keep it running smoothly as can be. My feelings on the Flaming if you can't take the heat don't play with fire, simple as that, to bad more people don't see it the same way and get upset when they freely volunteered themselves and boards to be honestly critiqued.

Once more a Big Thank you.

ShinLi - June 11, 2008 03:57 PM (GMT)
The system is all worked out, the forum and guidelines are actually made. I'm just waiting until more staff get back from busy lifes/schools/exams. Because yeh, can't do everything with only a few active mods around.

It will sure get up once Royle gets back from his busy exam stuff, as he was gonna mod that forum ^_^. Just hold on tight!

Jalynn - June 11, 2008 05:04 PM (GMT)
sneaks back to give ShinLi a big Hug.. AWESOME.. that is so great and I can not wait till that happens.




Hosted for free by InvisionFree